Cancer and Bhagavad Gita

It is very common for patients and concerned relatives ask me “doctor, will cancer come back? Can we cure this cancer?” Well, the answer is complicated. Often I have had to explain and give an example of Bhagavad Gita to explain how cancer treatment works. Gita is not referred to in religious context, but as a practical guide to understand the situation.

“कर्मणये वाधिकारस्ते मां फलेषु कदाचन । मां कर्मफलहेतुर्भू: मांते संङगोस्त्वकर्मणि” ।। (Bhagwat Gita: Chapter Two verse 47). This simply means ‘focus on the task at hand, don’t let the actions hinge on the outcome’.

How is Cancer Treated?

Cancer is treated based on cancer treatment protocols which are specific for a given stage of cancer. Most cancer patients will need at least two types of treatment out of three main modalities; surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy.

Surgery is the most efficient way to cure cancer. The idea of surgery is to remove all visible cancer. If that is not possible, which can happen sometimes, then surgery fails to serve its purpose. In most of the cases when surgery is adequate, despite technological advances there is no way to know if there are cancer cells left at the end of treatment or surgery. All these cases are treated based on the stage of cancer. There are protocols for almost every stage of cancer as to how to treat. These protocols are based on extensive research or consensus.

There are some cancers where radiation and chemotherapy are offered as main treatments. In these situations, a follow-up with scan (like PET CT) would be essential to assess the response.

Beat Your Enemy Incessantly.

Many of my patients ask me if they could do some scans and avoid next treatment. However, the idea of cancer treatment is not to look for cancer cells and treat, but, to treat it before cancer cells grow enough to be seen. You want to defeat cancer and to do this you need to beat it incessantly. This is an intense war. That is the reason why cancer treatment protocols don’t give too much time in between. If we give gaps in the treatment, the cancer cells get time to regenerate. The treatment is sequenced in such a way that the body gets time to recover and the next attack is made.

If we wait for cancer to grow till it becomes visible on scans and then treat, you would have wasted valuable time. The disease would have regained strength.

Can We Predict Cancer Outcomes?

We can predict cancer outcomes only to a certain extent. We know for example that a patient with a stage 1 cancer is likely to do better than stage 3 or 4. Here the word likely is very important. This denotes that there would be some patients who defy this rule. In statistical terms, we talk about percentages. Even when we say your chance of cure is 90%, we actually mean to say that you could also be in the 10% who are unlucky to get cancer back. This despite doing the same treatment.

We also know that some cancers have better outcomes than others. For example, the cancer of thyroid and testis can most of the times be cured. We know that the hormone receptor-positive breast cancer behaves much better than a negative one. We have also some genetic markers (Oncotype Dx, MammaPrint, etc) that can predict outcomes in breast cancer patients thus giving an opportunity to avoid chemotherapy. Again these are statistical.  This is by far we can go.


Focus on Task…

The verse mentioned above asks us to focus on the task, not on the result. This is exactly what the cancer treatment protocols tell us. The idea is to do what is the standard of care today and observe over years. Cure from cancer is declared only after 5 years of treatment completion. In that, the first 2 years are considered as the period of intense follow-up. Cancer can come back even after that, however, the risk is much less.

We do not have answers for everything. What we know is that each person’s cancer is different. Some do very well with very advanced stages of cancer, whereas, some with early cancers get back their cancer. This mystery is yet to be solved.

By Dr Sandeep Nayak

Author is a leading surgical oncologist of Bangalore presently heading MACS Clinic as well as Fortis Hospital, Bangalore. He is a well acclaimed specialist in robotic and laparoscopic cancer surgeries. He has been a teaching faculty at Kidwai Cancer Institute, Bangalore, which is one of the leading teaching institutes in Oncology in India. He has keen interest in public education and awareness. He shares his thoughts and facts on this blog.